| The pre-Budget report |
|
|
|
| Thursday, 10 December 2009 | |
|
The pre-Budget report brought announced 1.5 per cent rises in child and disability benefits in 2010 - the year of the general election - at a cost of £700 million. But the independent Institute for Fiscal Studies said the same benefits will be cut again the following year. In a BBC Radio Four interview, Mr Darling confirmed that he had brought forward increases in benefits, saying that because those benefits are linked to inflation, the alternative would have been no increase at all. He said: "I thought it was better to do that than a situation where benefits were frozen. I quite deliberately brought them forward, otherwise we would have a situation where benefits were frozen." The IFS said: "The 1.5 per cent rise, costing £700 million, is set to be only temporary, as the Chancellor committed himself - or rather, his successor - to increase these same benefits by 1.5 per cent less than inflation this time next year." Asked if the benefits will indeed fall again a year later, Mr Darling said: "We will look again in 12 months." George Osborne, the shadow chancellor, said Mr Darling had missed an opportunity "to be honest with the public" and accused him of a "pre-election con" in trumpeting positive measures that would have to be paid for later. Mr Osborne also repeated his pledge that a future Tory government would seek to reduce already-planned increases in National Insurance contributions. More than 10 million Britons will pay more national insurance from 2011 after changes announced in the pre-Budget report; someone earning a £50,000 salary will pay an extra £253 a year. The Chancellor also announced a freeze in a key income tax threshold to push more income into the 40 per cent tax band. The Treasury will take more money in inheritance tax and levy a new tax on financial workers' bonuses. Pension relief will be cut for some high earners and taxes will rise on company cars and workplace canteens. Hundreds of thousands will be pushed into the higher rate of income tax for the first time from 2012. Existing higher rate taxpayers will see more of their income taxed at 40 per cent. In total, Mr Darling announced £3 billion of new taxes on middle-class Britain in 2011, which will come on top of around £4 billion announced earlier this year. The package of taxes drew a barrage of criticism. Business leaders called the NI rise "a tax on jobs" and "an act of madness". Mr Darling said the tax rises are needed to help control the Government's record deficit, but the Tories said most of the £8.5 billion he will raise in two years from 2011 will actually go to fund more spending on Labour's chosen public services. He denied the early rise in benefits was a pre-election trick, saying the measure was designed to help recipients through the recession. The Chancellor also attempted to calm City fears by announcing that he would halve the Government's deficit in four years time by increasing taxes and squeezing some Whitehall departments' budgets. But he insisted that spending on schools, hospitals and the police will still rise, rejecting Conservative calls to cut deeper and quicker into the public sector. According to the independent Institute for Fiscal Studies, Mr Darling has actually increased the Government's planned spending by £15 billion over two years from 2011. Admitting that the UK economy will shrink by 4.5 per cent this year, a peacetime record, Mr Darling said that borrowing will be higher than he had forecast, reaching £178 billion this year. Despite Mr Darling's promises to curb the annual Government over-spend, the nation's accumulated debt will go on rising, hitting £1.5 trillion in five years. Mr Darling said that the City bankers and public sector workers will also have to pay for Labour's plans. Banks paying bonuses will now have to pay a one-off 50 per cent levy. However, the tax will raise only a modest sum and sparked predictions that it will be widely avoided. Millions of public sector workers will effectively take a pay cut from 2011 after Mr Darling said annual rises will be capped at 1 per cent, below the expected rate of inflation. But risking controversy, it emerged that MPs will not be covered by the cap, and remain in line for a big pay rise under new expenses rules. The unexpected rise in NI, which will hit all those earning more than £20,000, was the most striking announcement in Mr Darling's speech. He said there would be another 0.5 per cent increase in National Insurance contributions - effectively a rise in income tax. It will come into force in 2011 alongside a previous 0.5 per cent rise. Defending the tax rises Mr Darling said: "The biggest burden will fall on those with the broadest shoulders." Privately, senior Treasury sources said the NI rise was the least painful way to raise money for Labour's plans. Mr Darling is understood to have considered and rejected increasing VAT to 18 or 19 per cent. Mr Darling told MPs Labour's plans would restore growth to the economy. The UK economy is "on the road to recovery," he said, predicting robust growth by 2011. Rejecting Conservative calls to reduce the deficit faster, he said: "The choices are between going for growth or putting the recovery at risk. To reduce the deficit while protecting front-line services, or cuts which put these services in danger." In the Commons, there were jeers from the the opposition benches as Mr Darling claimed he was setting out his plans "from a position of strength''. The rise in national insurance was a surprise, and Labour ministers were forced to defend the move. Yvette Cooper, the Work and Pensions Secretary, said it was "proportionate" that those earning £20,000 would pay more tax. Richard Lambert, the CBI Director-General, said: "The Chancellor has made a serious mistake imposing an extra jobs tax at a time when the economic recovery will still be fragile. Increasing the National Insurance contribution will hold back job creation and growth." Stephen Robertson, director general of the British Retail Consortium, said: "This is madness. This makes it more expensive for all businesses to maintain and create jobs." |
| < Prev | Next > |
|---|


